SUfag here, can confirm that SVTFOE is better. I love SU to bits (or at least used to), but it's so goddamn inconsistent, especially during the current season. I feel that the show is stagnating, to be honest.
SVTFOE, on the other hand, only seems to get better and better. I hated it at first, but it grew so much on me. At least the writing is consistent in it.