I was never really into /co/ stuff but it got some attention on /a/ too for being a "western magical girl" show. I remember there was a thread with some clips from the first episode when it premiered, and like most people I thought Star's voice didn't fit at all and thought Pony Head was fucking ridiculously obnoxious. The porn was great though, definitely kept it on my radar even if I never intended to actually watch it.
I didn't actually get interested in the show until February when someone crossposted screencaps of "Running With Scissors" and THAT webm from Bon Bon The Birthday Clown, and I couldn't believe it was from the same lolrandum meme show. I binged everything in like two days, just in time for "The Hard Way" and I've been obsessed with Star since then.