>>91337070So the first question is if we include male heroes and villains. For purposes of this, let's say no. Standard shenanigans about booking multiple dates the same night won't work because there are too many telepaths. Instead I suggest a reality show.
Some villain with reality-warping powers stages a reality show where one 'lucky' man must date every female superhero and supervillain at the same time, The Bachelor-style, slowly removing one per episode (though given the sheer volume, probably more like five per episode). And that lucky man will be chosen randomly, and it just so happens to be Peter Parker. Of course, everything will be on live TV.
But the supervillains continue to do their supervillain shtick, so Peter has to dodge the cameras by doing things like going to the bathroom, taking a nap, etc, while the girls talk to the cameras about how much they hope they win, and foils the villains.