After eight/nine months since Rebirth started, here's the scores of DC Rebirth books from the critics:

7.6 Action Comics (2016)
8.3 All-Star Batman
7.8 Aquaman (2016)
7.6 Batgirl (2016)
6.7 Batgirl and the Birds of Prey
7.8 Batman (2016)
7.1 Batman Beyond (2016)
7.5 Blue Beetle (2016)
6.9 Cyborg (2016)
7.9 Deathstroke (2016)
8.2 Detective Comics (2016)
8.0 Flash (2016)
8.0 Green Arrow (2016)
7.4 Green Lanterns
8.0 Hal Jordan And The Green Lantern Corps
7.9 Harley Quinn (2016)
7.0 Hellblazer (2016)
6.7 Justice League (2016)
8.1 New Superman
7.8 Nightwing (2016)
8.1 Red Hood and the Outlaws (2016)
7.9 Suicide Squad (2016)
7.4 Supergirl (2016)
8.4 Superman (2016)
7.0 Superwoman
7.5 Teen Titans (2016)
7.7 Titans (2016)
7.9 Trinity (2016)
8.6 Wonder Woman (2016)

WW, Superman, ASM, TEC and RHATO/NSM (tie) have the highest score with Wondy in the lead.

BOP, Cyborg, BB, JL and Superwomen/Hellblazer (tie) have the lowest score with BOP being the worst.