Quoted By:
I'll give it to Andrew, followed by McGuire and Holland in third place.
But I had to mention that Holland wi'll be at some point the best, has he has already shown a lot of potential, his spider sense works with more anticipation, has displayed a good amount of strenght , fighting skills and agility, but is very unexperienced yet.
Tobey has apparently the biggest amount of power, has the organic web and can resist a lot of punishment, the thing with McGuire portrayal is that he's commonly outmatched by his enemies, and is a quitter in general, I'll take Ock train match has his prime, he displayed the most of his powers, he showed his peak strenght, stamina and agility...
The thing with Andrew's portrayal is that he has the most skills using his powers, and more determination, we saw Tobey saved multiple persons being thrown by doc. ock and jumping through narrow spaces in seconds... but in the electro battle we saw Andrew moving at bullet speed, stoping a flying car, and a dozen of civilians from being electrocuted with only one functional web shooter, also he has been shown evading multiple bullets at close range, and carrying a fight with a shot wounded leg against the lizard, so a close call with Tobey but gotta give it to Andrew... plus, he's not a whiny bitch.