I'm sorry, but I don't ever really see his super-strength or quick reflexes on display in the Maguire Spider-Man movies.
Whereas in Amazing, Garfield's Spider-Man is all over the place, constantly leaping around and on the move, taking full advantage of his agility.
Plus there's that scene in Amazing-2 where he saves a half-dozen people from Electro, with only one functional webshooter at the time, *and* catches a police car like it's no big thing.
Sorry, but no. Amazing Spider-Man just comes across as better than Maguire Spider Man.
Hence the title.
Add in the fact that he actually wisecracks like he's supposed to, and a far better score, and yeah. I just massively prefer Amazing and Amazing-2 to any of the Maguire movies. Spider-Man 2 was pretty good but mostly because of Mr. Doc Ock Freeze, not Spider-Man.