>>109498977Possibly, though I think it has more to do with intent or the feelings behind the burial.
Like when Reggie buried her toys and the cardboard ship she had happy feelings towards them and they came back good.
She had negative feelings towards the puberty books and the label maker when they were thrown in their liquids so they came back as monsters.
Also, when Todd tried to make his brother Aaron a second time he felt anger when burying his objects and so the creature also came out as a monster, albeit a relatively harmless one.
So while she might've had a different form Butt Witch would most likely still have been summoned.
Or if not her -some- sort of puberty monster would've came out.
