>>101711478>Theyvhad small amounts of petsonalities, like Sibella was polite, somewhat playful, and arguably the nicest member of the group. People could take what little they had and expand on that, but some instead just choose to scrap everything and make shit up. Bitter drunk Sibella is a very big departure, and I can't even say she has more personality than the original so she doesn't even have that going for her.I don't disagree with you on that point(for example I hate the "bitter eternal loli" personality many people here give Tanis), might have to give the movie a proper rewatch to figure out how to properly flesh out their personalities
>>101712112>Phantasma may just be the best design in the film.true
>Sibella had a great design, but the movie's wonky animation didn't do it justice.also true
>Elsa's design gets way too much hate here in my opinion. I like her ugly-cute look even if she had the same issue Sibella did.honestly not much needs to truly be changed for Elsa, the main issue in retrospect was her face was just a touch too detailed for it's own good, also while it's not necessary, I do feel it's a nice tweak that a lot of the artists who redesign her give her a different skin tone, the one she has in the movie is just a touch too normal for a Frankenstoid
>Tanis' design was simple, but fuck was she adorable.agreed, it's telling that outside of the debate regarding whether to age her up properly or not, pretty much the only major change artists give to her design is to give her a proper outfit instead of just bandages
>Winnie peobably had the weakest design of that group, but I don't hate it. I'm not really a fan of the redesign that gets posted.agreed the Flannel look is just really bland, also while I don't mind her being short, she shouldn't be such a twig like many of the redesigns have her be, it is definitely a challenge to find the right balance between Wolf and Girl for her though
