>>101549008Well Blue-shirt Donald has featured in many shorts and has ability to tap into the Toon Force. However, because the nature of those shorts has him often be the butt of the joke, it would be a double edged sword and most likely work against him as much as with him.
Meanwhile, Black-shirt Donald, while lacking the sheer reality warping abilities of Blue-shirt, does have the same legendary toughness, strength, and persistence of him, as well as a track record of clever plans that only foul up half the time.
There’s also the question of how either Donald’s innate rage plays into it. Putting aside 3C’s Blue-shirt Donald, who has learned to temper, contorl, and harness his rage upon a whim, Blue-shirt’s more ornery nature would actually help him here to be provoke into Duck Rage quicker, which coupled with the Toonforce, would be incredibly destructive, although to whom or what is anyone’s guess. Meanwhile, Black shirt Donald, while still petty, vindictive, and short-tempered, is relativey calmer and takes a lot more provocation to enter his rage state. However, on those occasions when he does get pushed beyond the limit, his anger is less impotent and more focused, and usually gets things done.
TL:DR Blue-shirt has more raw power and can use it more easily, but Black-shirt can use his more effectively.