Need opinions on new feature in art critique platform

No.5810488 ViewReplyOriginalReport
Hi, we are developing the "timeline" feature.

What does it do? It links your work to an older version of it. It essentially shows progress over time. Or at least, that's what we're hoping it ends up doing.

We were wondering if we should lock the ability to get reviews on older posts in the timeline or not.
-The reasoning behind locking is that when you're posting newer versions, you learned from last time and improved it, so there's no reason to get critiques on the older version anymore.
-The reasoning behind leaving it open is to make the users feel less restricted and it's less complicated to implement

a) locking b)not locking

Please let us know which option is best in your opinion.

We also were wondering about which timeline popup we should go for. 1, 2 or something else entirely?

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year