>>87240266'Edgy', when used as a pejorative, doesn't mean 'dark', it means 'trying, visibly, to be upsetting for no purpose beyond trying to be upsetting but only in such a way as to appeal to people who like 'evil stuff'.' Edgy things are rarely grim or anything, they're generally just absurd. It's usually more about the execution, as well.
For example, a small-time criminal with track marks is, perhaps, edgy without being 'edgy'. A small time criminal who growls something about how being a junkie has turned him into a monster and how the noble protagonist is just a pawn of the MAN, that's probably 'edgy'.
Not, to be fair, that I'm disagreeing with you. Just providing a more complete picture.
