2's got the nicest dick. This with a nice, mouth-watering head. I don't like his face but I like his cock. He'd be cool as a dildo.
3's got the ideal body type, not fond of redheads though. I'd be fine with light ginger. His dick's fine too as long as he knows it'll be used for bullying mostly. Fat nipples are meh though. Guess that'd be another reason to bully him. My overall favorite.
4's got the kind of vibe that makes you want to fuck with him. His dick's so red it looks like it's been denied for weeks and he looks way too serious. I'd want to break him, nothing more, nothing less.