There is a bit more to that event>riding around>see corpse near the water>investigate>its a severaly decayed body with some large contraption around their neck>check them and they have a note>it talks about being held captive in that house basement and that the man was capturing free'd slaves to sell them there despite slavery being outlawed and wasnt feeding them, just torturing them
Its why there is a bunch of instruments on the walls in the basement, he wasnt just keeping slaves he was torturing them and enedvouring to recapture those that were once slaves, he kept a log of it in the house if you found it.
I mean, it still shouldnt give points for any kind of killing let alone good points.
Heres one>sneak into cabin since I hear people talking inside>encounter black man and his son in a cabin>man is drunk and talks about the boy making money, and the boy says whats the point since the father just spends it on drink>the man hits the boy and the boy runs out of the room>he sees me and gets scared>man tells me to leave>just leave>as soon as I go to ride away he starts fucking shooting at me and talking shit>kill him>bad points>go back inside>boy is hiding under the bed>option to threaten him for money>dont take it, just leave>return a long time later>thought the house was empty, it looks abandoned and shit is lying all over the place, until I go into the boys room, hes on the bed reading a book>"not you again, this time Im ready!">pulls a fucking knife>give him the rope-a-dope>bad points
I mean, you shouldnt be just walking into peoples houses but fuck.