I'm sorry i was super tired and just fell asleep.
Also i would've had to write out a whole story for this and while MacGyver was alwas a favorite i have absolutely no idea how to outwit supernatural creatures.
I definitely would've picked the dolly, and was undecided about the lantern, but having looked at the results, i'd rather take WD42.
Because liquefying things is super cool.
Make Dolly a hulking behemoth suit out of random dirt, equip it with the flask and watch it liquefy the organs of non supernatural enemies.
Also liquefying my prosthetic leg and molding it back onto my leg might make it take on the properties of ... my leg, getting rid of the unsightly unfeeling outer shell of the cybernetic limb replacing it with skin hopefully.
Also i always thought that that red eyed monster is pretty neat.
...Yeah i could sit around and look at it for a while, sure.
And while we're at it the xeno hunters seem ... alright.
They're not explicitly hunting anyone and it's more than likely that the xenos and the marines and them will all take care of each other.
Offering them some help with the xenos might net me a nice forehead tattoo
Well the Notebook is also pretty cool because it can conceivably make all the other items.
Also, with the car being close by, me outrunning anything with my new limb, and the gun shop also nearby, i'm sure i could get some more paperclips
Soooo, after all this being said, the thing i need the most is the binoculars to get me away from here safely, so i can come back with more paperclips and guns.
Also we have a curious lack of electricity around, which sucks, because high voltage electric fences and traps are perfect not-necessarily-lethal defenses against any of these asshats. So some generators with fuel for a while and lots of wiring will be the first thing i bring apart from guns and paperclips for the notebook.
Alternatively the other two paperclips get combined and used on macgyver.