This. Most people I know, unless they're massive /a/ fags who like moe and shit, are still stuck on the same handful of anime/manga; JoJo, Berserk, NGE, DBZ/Super, FMA, Naruto, Cowboy Bebop, Fist of the North Star, maybe Hellsing, maybe One Piece, etc.
Either that or they're still getting over all the essentials and knocking off a few series before they get into new shit. It's hard to watch a lot of anime and still have an actual life, a lot harder than it is to be into any /co/ media. I can read like 10 comics on my ride home on the train, I couldn't do the same with any anime.