I'm a big Renner fan and comic book Hawkeye isn't really a stud type drawn character, he's not even typically lean muscle buff/body builder buff (at least in his main books for the past few runs). But he's not the most attractive man in films. Pratt's kinda boringly bland attractive, added to by his weight loss and personality, but Renner just comes across as too boring in personality and a bit grumpy (again, without the charm the comic books can pull off with rumpled Hawkguy).
Evans is definitely the top draw and Scar Jo as well, as far as looks, personality/charisma (as far as being appealing appearance-wise). But ounce for ounce, the DCWverse is probably more attractive overall as to leads/co-leads than the Netflix Marbleverse, AoS/Agent Carter, or the MCU.