>>116329729>Sith is just as badly written, acted and filmed as Menace and ClonesWrong. Obi-Wan's "You were the chosen one...! I loved you etc." speech is a moment that has stronger emotional impact than those two movies, making it automatically superior.
> Lucas made no effort to improve upon his craft. All of the flaws are still there.Also wrong.
>The movie is not emotionally engagingOnce again, Obi-Wan on Mustafar. Also, how the fuck is it not emotionally engaging? It's a classical tragedy. One man loses everything, especially himself, out of the fear of losing everything. That's a story as old as time itself, and one we can all relate to.
>Anakin's turn fails to be satisfying Agreed, it goes by a little too fast but it's still convincing, just rushed. The Younglings were a step too far.
>Keep in mind I haven't watched Clone Wars 2008 yetOpinion discarded, watch it and you'll see why people love and defend these movies - because their flaws were remedied by that series.
>If i need to watch a tv show first in order to be invested in the film, then the film fails to accomplish its goal ( nevermind that Clone Wars didn't even exist in 2005 )You... don't? You just said TCW didn't exist in 2005. You can watch this franchise in any order you wish, you do know that, right?
>Filoni shouldn't have to do Lucas's dirty workLucas was involved in TCW.
