>>113407561Doomsday Cock features great artwork, some superficially interesting concepts, and does just enough of a clumsy job being faux Moore that you can almost overlook the fact that the story has no point (beyond establishing Superman is still great) and butcher's Manhattan's character to simply exist. Plus Batman Batmans in it; which is an automatic added star for anyone who consooms DC comics.
Watchmen the HBO series (or as I call it Doctor Manhattan vs the Klan) features some solid production values, decent acting and seems to want to explore a few good ideas, but noone is clumsily trying to Moore anything, and the whole thin premise only works because they complete butcher Dr. Manhattan's character. Also, at no point does Batman even appear, let alone do some decent Batmanning.
So Advantage: comic.
I'd feel badly if I spent a nickel on either though.
There was a time when I was naive enough to believe that Zack Snyder was the worst sort of adaptation of Alan Moore.
So the comic is
