>>112054845I mean I remember seeing theories like:
The rebellion was orchestrated by the Diamonds, and Rose was just following orders
It would be revealed that the Rebels were the bad guys all along. That the show would show that they were actually motivated by worse reasons then it originally seemed.
That the Gem Monsters would be revealed to be how Gems naturally are, and that sentient Gems are actually the corrupted/modified ones.
That one of the CGs would turn out to have been loyal to the diamonds all along
That the clusters were actually made by the rebellion not Homeworld
That Gem tech even the ones used by our protagonists were all powered by cracked Gems
That one of the CGS would turn out to be a Diamond in disguise (Which I guess Pink being Rose was a part of)
That fucking Connie would be revealed to be a Diamond is disguise
And that's only the stuff at the top of my head, point is that there were many theories that were in the same ballpark of magnitude of Rose being Pink, and most of them were considered to be crack.