I rated it by either being the most compelling storywise or being an actually good person that helps others in one way or another. Those that contributed little or any as far as stand-ins or otherwise were unlikable were put lower.
Jasmine - genuinely good person, tries to help friends and others, goes out of her way
Rachel - much like Jasmine, puts others before herself and has a good heart
Augustus - compelling backstory and angst
Abbey - despite the retard anger management stuff (depending on chapter how well its done) interesting backstory and character arc with flaws obviously
Molly - tries to help her brother, pretty innocuous of a character
Matt - compelling angst - tries to help others, again pretty harmless.
Amaya - adds nothing to the story or character-wise but is fine
Jordan - a good person, unlike his siblings and tries to help others
Paulo - annoying as fuck at times, but some of the best stories involve him - go between despising and tolerating him.
Sue - a bit too holier then thou but generally tries to do 'the right thing' and sort of stays out of drama, otherwise bland
David - walking meme, non consequential but ok for some bad jokes
Mike - generic animu protag turned raging sperg, but he is sometimes nice and his angst is a bit compelling..unfortunately that is all he has going for him.
Sandy - at least more interesting then Lucy and has potential for a great story arc (like that'd ever happen lmao)
Daisy - two faced,petty, childish and an attention whore. Not even cutesy antics can really save this character, plus the shitty-ness she put Abbey thru
Jessica - just has nothing going for her, even the party/cool girl aesthetic is kind of erased -she is just kind of there as Lucy's ex-admirer and friend of Rachel.
Tess- She was never an interesting character and never did anything of note. More forgettable then Sue
Lucy - Mary-sue, terrible person, angst and drama is not compelling only melodramatic and lame.
Madison- the worst.