>>106134392>Do you know why Lucas added the conversation between Windu, Yoda and Obi-Wan about the prophecy in Rots? To show that they had no doubt that Anakin was the chosen one, what they had doubts about was the content of the prophecy. They were worried that he wasn't actually meant to bring balance and destroy the sith, but he was meant for something else which is why Yoda said that it could be misread and why they were wary of him. So, Anakin's fall wouldn't suddnly make Obi Wan and Yoda stop believing that he is the chosen one, it would be just a confirmation of what they feared.No one is saying it would suddenly do so. But that scene takes place before Anakin falls to the Dark Side and betrays everyone. Obi-Wan very easily could have sat on Tatooine for years thinking over everything that happened and then considered the possibility that Luke was the chosen one instead and chose to believe that.
>And the scene in Rebles doesn't only contradict the movies, It doesn't. Again, the movies never claim anything about what Obi-Wan thinks about the Chosen One prophecy. For there to be a contradiction, the opposite claim would have had to have been made. Obi-Wan's beliefs in ROTS do not necessarily reflect his beliefs 20 years later
>it's also very pointless because we already know that it's not Luke the point of the scene is to show that Obi-Wan believes Luke is the chosen one, not to try and make us think Luke is the Chosen One. God you're stupid.
>and stupid because how did Maul learned about the prophecy and why would he care?Maul could have learned of it any number of ways, the Prophecy was never said to have only been known by the Jedi. As to why he cares? Literally his last words "He... will... avenge.. us."
Maul wanted revenge on Sheev for how he was wronged, and for Savage. The Chosen One is supposed to destroy the Sith and bring Balance to the Force. So by destroying the Sith, the Chosen One will inadvertently be avenging Maul and Savage.
