This, like pic related. But different girls like different types. I think I can narrow it down to confidence.
If the guy has high confidence, he can look like anything. A slob, a pretty boy, ugly, a fit guy, the girls that like these men are standard. They want a protector, a prince in pink slippers.
If the guy has low confidence, he has to be attractive. A whimp, a slob, a nerd but still attractive. These women want to be the protectors, mothers, and have a project.