Good categories, bad presentation.
Waifus: Only bad waifu is Amethyst, but she is bad enough to warrant a deduction of 2. Garnet is also a boring choice, but I can sorta see it. Pearl is best waifu. Greg is best husbando. 8/10.
Drama: Good when done correctly- which is surprisingly often- but when done poorly it is... cringe. Really goddamn cringe. S5 has more-or-less avoided this, thankfully, but S4 and S3 having staggeringly bad drama. 7/10
Action: Usually bad. Everyone knows this. 2/10.
Comedy: Depends on the boarder. I'd average a 6/10.
Lore: Oozes charm and potential-- so much so that even with the lackluster capitalization on said potential, it's still just damn charming. 9/10.
Story: Hiatuses killed the story, but without those... 7/10. It isn't as bad you think it is.
Writing Quality: Again, depends of the boarder. However, since Zuke got juked, the quality of writing has skyrocketed across the board. 7/10.
Character Design: Smokey Quartz is morbidly obese
hideous. Most characters-- barring maybe Pearl, Jasper, and the Bismuth-- are average. All the Diamonds are fucking fantastic, as are MOST of the fusions.