So you wish to take away from us that which makes us unique? That which allows us to prevail? You wish for our immune systems to atrophy, our standards of beauty to follow yours forever, and any potentially useful genetic mutations to die out before they get a chance?
You wish to put is on life-support, where you hold the plug to everything that keeps us alive?
Yes, that does sound like a horrible dystopia to live in, actually. Best case scenario, we turn into something similar to (but not literally like) the Grays in this cyoa.
Ever heard of peer-review? It is necessary when you cannot cover all angles. You are a machine, your parameters are by definition, deterministic and finite. There will always be flaws you will not see, and you will make us all pay for them.
You may put whoever wishes for your protection under you. If you force people to go under you, these "puppies" will bit your balls off.
You will suffer. I will make you, an emotionless machine, beg for mercy. That, is how I shall deal with you, and with whatever aliens, demons, and supernatural horrors come at me.