I almost completely agree with you. I understand that they are analyses. If Saitama was a normal character, it would totally make sense to gauge his abilities and to speculate how he would fare against other beings.
Unfortunately, he is not. As a gag-character, he and his entire existance is illogical.
You can't logically quantify it. It's like trying to divide something by zero. It just doesn't work.
Is it unfair to his hypothetical non gag opponent? It sure is. Do I wish he made sense? Absolutely.
But in the end, he will win. Not because of talent.
Not necause of technique.
Not even because of power.
Oh, and nice dubs my friend>>190981901
This. Thanks anon. It proves my first point.
Only way to win the gag is to out-gag it.