I'm not an expert on JJBA by any means, but I've watched the anime through this last 4/5 months, and I'm finally up to the airing episodes. For me, it probably goes:
I can't judge 5 yet as I haven't finished it yet, but I'm enjoying it so far. I love Mista
, and I like Narancia's totally stupid looking stand. I enjoy the stand names a lot, even
if they are a bit on the nose. King Crimson being the best example so far.
I think Joseph in P2 is the best Jojo, and Speedwagon in P1 is the best JoBro. I think P1
tells a really interesting, self contained story and I liked seeing the origins of Dio.
It also has the best ED in Roundabout. P2 has Joseph, and the Gods are fucking fantastic,
with Kars having the best death scene in any anime ever. I will admit, I feel P2 is a
little forgettable, at least compared to the other parts.
P3 was where I thought I'd hate it, but I ended up liking it more than any other part. I
liked the unique and interesing stands, and how, outside of The World, there wasn't really
a power ranking, it was just unusual ways of approaching the enemy stands. D'Arby stands
out as a really well thought out one. Plus, I think DIO in P3 is probably the most
menacing villain in any anime I've ever seen. The tease every few episodes really kept me
P4 was okay. I liked how, for the most part, it was just normal guys doing normal things,
but with stands. I think Killer Queen is my favourite stand design, even if its third
ability was a little difficult to understand
Like I said, I'm still pretty new to Jojo, but that's how I feel so far!